Saturday, October 8, 2011

Table Saw without `saw stop' technology defective: First Circuit

photo by FineWoodworking magazine
Carlos Osorio suffered serious hand injuries at work while using a Ryobi portable table saw.  He filed a multi-count complaint alleging negligence and breach of the seller's duty Massachusetts doctrine of implied warranty.   The First Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals in Osorio v. One World Technologies has upheld a plaintiff's verdict based on the claim that a table saw was defective due to failure to include automatic instant braking technology such as that invented by Stephen Gass - the founder of Saw Stop who lauded the verdict in a Q&A with FineWoodworking magazine.  The company has promoted its product with its famous hot dog video.

Patrick McCombe, a FineWoodworking reporter has an interesting review of the defense tactics and the plaintiff's countermeasures here.

Fine Woodworking, which has covered the Osorio case closely reports that on October 5, 2011 - the day the First Circuit affirmed the $1.5 million plaintiff's verdict - the Consumer Product Safety Commission voted 5-0 to issue an advance notice of proposed rulemaking for a new power saw safety rule. [The CPSC briefing package is HERE.]  Gass has been pressing for such a rule for 8 years.

One of the "risk utility factors" in a design defect case is the cost and practicality of the proposed alternative safer design.  This article from FineWoodworking includes a price list.  The SawStop cabinet saw commands a premium price that could make a real difference to a consumer.

After that view an ad for a SawStop portable contractor's saw which is twelve times the price of the Ryobi.
A competing designer David  Butler - a blade brake inventor - is working to adapt the technology to portable contractors saws. VIDEO HERE
10 inch professional cabinet saw

updated February 10, 2014


  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

  2. The blade defend is exceedingly spontaneous using a fresh split-guarding technology gives exceptional line of perception and also utmost safety. The Bosch 4100-09 Easily transportable Dining room table Found relies on a effective base including in-built moving handle side grips pertaining to simple and fast transport. Other enhancements include a single-point bevel movement pertaining to reliable perfection best portable table saw, together with exceptional airborne debris series.

  3. I am going to buy miter saw. I read many website and I see Dewalt DW175 which suitable my need. I am going to buy this site . But I don’t know where is the best seller about miter saw. Give me your opinions