Wednesday, January 2, 2013

Social Withdrawal and Violence — Newtown, Connecticut — New England Journal of Medicine

Social Withdrawal and Violence — Newtown, Connecticut — NEJM: by John T. Walkup, M.D., and David H. Rubin, M.D
"In the aftermath of the great tragedy in Newtown, Connecticut, the mental health community is responding to our own and others' desperation to understand why this event occurred and is advocating for strategies that might prevent similar events in the future. Discussion has focused on whether Adam Lanza was mentally ill, the risk of violence among the mentally ill, access to high-quality mental health care, gun control, and the relationship between the media and violence. An important dimension that has been less discussed is the question of social withdrawal and isolation, within and beyond the confines of mental illness. For the withdrawn and isolated and the angry and alienated, there are deep-seated barriers to care, and there may exist a small subgroup that is uniquely vulnerable to the seductive power of violence in our culture."...
The tragedy in Newtown has revived many Americans' passion for gun control and has drawn attention to the media's influence on violent behavior. What is missing from most related discussions is a focus on the seductive, powerful subculture that celebrates and advocates violent and antisocial behavior. Most people are not interested in and do not engage with this subculture, and most who do so are not seduced into action by antisocial themes and violence in films, video games, written materials, or interest groups. However, a very small minority of angry and alienated mentally ill persons may gain a sense of belonging and support from this subculture and may be particularly vulnerable to being seduced into action.
As we launch into relevant policy debates, mental health professionals are best tasked with addressing the problems in our system that make it difficult for individuals and their loved ones to obtain effective, high-quality mental health care early in life. Since most psychiatric disorders begin in childhood or adolescence, more research is needed on the progression of mental health problems from childhood through adolescence and into adulthood. More specifically, research is needed to elucidate the multiple trajectories of the early withdrawn and isolated behavior that is so common in the reported histories of people who perform violent acts. Finally, discussions of gun control and violence in the media need to delve deeper and illuminate the dark subculture of alienation and antisocial violence that may engage and seduce rare individuals into performing extreme acts of violence like the one in Newtown."

'via Blog this'

No comments:

Post a Comment